Asia Pacific

Manila, 3 June 2024  – The Asia Clean Energy Forum (ACEF) 2024 hosted by the Asian Development Bank (ADB) is underway amid escalating climate challenges and economic pressures across low- and middle-income countries in the region. This year’s forum, however, is drawing significant criticism from NGO Forum on ADB, Alyansa Tigil Mina (ATM), Asian Peoples Movement on Debt and Development (APMDD), Center for Energy, Ecology and Development (CEED), Coalition for Human Rights in Development (CHRD), EcoWaste Coalition, Freedom from Debt Coalition, Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (GAIA), Legal Rights and Natural Resources Center (LRC-KSK), Philippine Legislators’ Committee on Population and Development, Philippine Movement for Climate Justice (PMCJ), Recourse, 350.org, and together with other organizations of the Philippine Working Group, argue that the event is more focused on advancing corporate interests than addressing the urgent need for equitable and sustainable climate solutions.

The Asia Pacific region has faced unprecedented heat waves and severe economic strain in 2024, exacerbated by the lingering effects of the pandemic and ongoing geopolitical conflicts. Communities, respected leaders, and advocates from various sectors have been steadfastly opposing the expansion of fossil gas infrastructure, the damming of rivers, destructive geothermal drilling, and waste incineration. They emphasize the intergenerational harms and losses these projects entail.

Despite the critical need for climate responsibility and affordable renewable energy access, the ACEF 2024 program appears to prioritize the interests of private companies historically responsible for greenhouse gas emissions and environmental damage. Notably, the forum’s opening plenary will feature senior management from Japan’s Marubeni and representatives from Keppel, both known for their support of fossil fuel projects.

ADB’s call for “quick win” solutions seems designed to benefit corporations rather than addressing the realities of planetary boundaries and the needs of marginalized communities. The absence of discussions on environmental and social governance further highlights the neglect of human and environmental rights in ADB’s energy investments, particularly in authoritarian and restrictive regimes.

ACEF 2024’s promotion of carbon removal technologies such as Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS) and emerging fuel mixes like green hydrogen has raised alarms. These technologies, often touted as solutions, have failed to deliver substantial reductions in carbon emissions and pose significant risks to local communities and ecosystems.

The forum also spotlights large hydropower projects and waste-to-energy incineration, both of which have been criticized for their environmental impact and unsustainable nature. Civil society groups argue that these approaches divert attention from genuinely sustainable solutions like decentralized, non-fossil fuel energy.

Concerns extend to ADB’s policy-based loans and sessions promoting reliance on liquefied natural gas (LNG), ammonia, hydrogen, and CCUS. These sessions, in partnership with Japan’s Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry, and the Korea Energy Agency, are seen as further entrenching dirty energy futures in Asia.

For the first time, ACEF 2024 will spotlight the critical minerals sector. Rather than addressing the human and environmental rights violations associated with mining, the forum paints an overly positive picture of countries like the Philippines, Indonesia, Mongolia, and Kazakhstan as key players in global value chains. Civil society groups warn against expanding mining operations that threaten local communities’ survival.

For nearly two decades, ACEF has facilitated a contentious consensus-building among private sector entities in the regional energy landscape. The promises of clean and affordable energy often mask the challenges of achieving a robust, just, equitable, and rights-based energy transition. Civil society groups urge ADB and other financial institutions to shift focus towards genuinely sustainable renewable energy solutions, rather than profit-driven technofixes.

As the impacts of climate change intensify, it is imperative that ADB and other global financial institutions are held accountable for historical and ongoing environmental and social harms. Forum network and allies call for an overhaul of the key policy initiatives discussed at ACEF 2024. With the upcoming Mid Term Energy Policy Review of the ADB, the CSOs call for an end to ADBs false solutions towards Just Transition and demand a full phase out from fossil fuels especially gas, and all forms of financing for coal. 

###

Alyansa Tigil Mina (ATM)

  1. We maintain that the ADB’s “climate-smart mining” ignores the negative impacts in mining-affected communities and that supply chains are not properly assessed. For instance, while the Green Climate Fund is investing heavily in e-mobility, sources of EV batteries are causing widespread destruction. On a more practical level, there is an urgent need to develop and implement a robust and expanded cost-benefit analysis (CBA)  of mining projects. These should incorporate the social and environmental costs as well as the impact to health and human rights brought about by the extractives industry. Unless these are determined and the impacts to the communities are considered more than the interests of profiteering corporations, there will only be more false solutions to the climate crisis.  We ask the public to join us in rejecting ADB’s techno fixes and their attempts to greenwash destructive mining operations. – Jaybee Garganera, National Coordinator, Alyansa Tigil Mina (ATM)
  1. We call on ACEF delegates to push for the implementation of policies for rapid, equitable, and just transition to 100% renewable sources of power by 2050 and do away with false solutions and technologies. Fossil fuel corporations and other ACEF participants are still putting false solutions on the table, such as hydrogen, carbon capture utilization and storage, ammonia, and promoting gas as a transition fuel. These are dirty sources of energy that only serve to entrench fossil fuels and continue to profit from them, ultimately delaying the clean energy transition.  – Lidy Nacpil, Coordinator, Asian Peoples Movement on Debt and Development (APMDD)
  1.  It is deeply disturbing that the organizers of the ACEF 2024 led by the Asian Development Bank (ADB) continue to promote energy sector investments that will not only delay our transition to renewable energy systems, but also mire our countries even deeper into debt. At this point, the idea of leveraging public funds to support continued investment in projects that only sidetrack us from our goal of a full transition away from fossil fuels is completely unacceptable.  In a country such as the Philippines, which is at the frontlines of climate change impacts, while also suffering from record levels of debt, to have these concerns completely ignored by a gathering that is held here every year, is nothing less than a slap in the face. – Rovik Obanil, Secretary General, Freedom from Debt Coalition
  1. The clean energy transition must not be justice-blind to the impacts of dirty technologies to people and the environment. We call on the ADB, international financial institutions, government agencies, and all energy investors to stop funding waste-to-energy incineration, refuse-derived fuel, carbon capture utilization and storage, coal co-firing, and other false solutions to waste and climate change. The fact that affected communities, informal sector workers, public transport workers, and civil society organizations are not identified as target participants in the ACEF is very telling of where investment priorities lie. A true clean and just energy transition must be inclusive, and recognize the solutions led by people and communities that are already producing positive impacts. – Miriam Azurin, Asia Pacific Deputy Director, Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (GAIA) Asia Pacific
  1. The current corporate-led approach to clean energy may exacerbate inequalities, as Indigenous communities often suffer the most from environmental damage, such as the exploitation of ancestral land, natural resources and water and lack of access to clean energy solutions.It is crucial to ensure fair access to clean energy for a smooth transition.  Decision- making process should involve Indigenous peoples’ more. Empowering IPs can result in more inclusive and sustainable energy solutions. A comprehensive approach that combines technology, social and policy measures is crucial. There is a need for a comprehensive strategy that tackles the root causes of climate change and promotes sustainable development. – Indira Shreesh, Founding member and Chairperson,  Indigenous Women Legal Awareness Group (INWOLAG)
  1. Clean energy could very well leave a huge negative environmental and social footprint. Renewable energy projects must always have a sustainability dimension, so as to avoid further harms to the environment and communities. Crucially, where these projects can be found in ancestral lands, the right to self-determination of indigenous peoples must be upheld and not be sacrificed to the transition. We are sounding off the exponential demand for energy transition minerals, half of which reserves are projected to be mined in ancestral lands. It will be the supreme irony that the energy transition shall also result in unabated mining, which often has irreversible deleterious effects on people and nature. –Maya Quirino, Advocacy Coordinator, Legal Rights and Natural Resources Center (LRC-KSK)
  1. As the impacts of climate change intensify, it is imperative that ADB and other global financial institutions are held accountable for historical and ongoing environmental and social harms. Forum network and allies call for an overhaul of the key policy initiatives discussed at ACEF 2024. With the upcoming Mid Term Energy Policy Review of the ADB, the NGO Forum on ADB and its allies call for an end to ADBs false solutions towards Just Transition and demand a full phase out from fossil fuels especially gas and all forms of financing for coal. – Rayyan Hassan, Executive Director, NGO Forum on ADB
  1. We don’t have any more time for false solutions that tie us to fossil fuels. We call on the ADB to withdraw financing of all fossil fuel projects, and instead invest in a just–not only clean–transition to renewable energy. We need enough resources to ensure that people and the environment can recover, and will be put front and center as we shift to renewables. This means that polluter countries also need to pay climate reparations to countries bearing the brunt of the climate crisis, like us. ADB is accountable for this, too, for funding coal projects in the Philippines. We need concrete solutions now, starting with the payment of this huge historical debt. – Erwin Puhawan, Luzon Coordinator, Philippine Movement for Climate Justice (PMCJ)
  1. There is no room for false solutions such as carbon capture, usage and storage (CCUS) and co-firing of power stations which further extends the use of fossil fuels if we are to keep global temperature rise within the 1.5C trajectory.  Extreme caution must be exercised by MDBs in supporting green hydrogen as its production can lead to displacement of communities from their lands and livelihoods, and can compete with freshwater needs.The energy transition should be designed with and aim to benefit the communities who had done least to cause climate change, including women and indigenous peoples. – Alison Doig, Senior Advisor, Recourse
  1. Heading into 2030, balancing equity, urgency, and ambition in our energy transformation is essential. It’s time to ditch harmful energy, invest in renewables, and ensure transparency and community involvement. This isn’t just about hitting Paris Agreement targets—it’s about redefining our development pathway for a thriving future. The climate movement must lead the charge, using bold actions to expose the myth that fossil fuels are necessary for progress. Decarbonization is not only possible; it’s the key to justice and sustainability. Let’s redirect resources towards a clean energy economy that empowers communities and prioritizes the planet over profits. The Asian Development Bank’s commitment to renewables is crucial for reshaping Asia’s energy landscape and driving us towards a fossil-free future. – Chuck Baclagon, Finance Campaigner 350.org Asia

Interview with Yunchia Luo and Yichun Lin by Dan Abril

In a small café in Taipei, a movement was born. In 1998, six individuals, primarily from academia, met to discuss a shared concern: the burgeoning issue of waste. Led by George Cheng, a finance specialist with a passion for environmental sustainability, the group embarked on a journey that would lead to the establishment of the Taiwan Watch Institute (TWI). 

Inspired by anti-incinerator movements abroad and fueled by collaborations with international bodies like GAIA, Cheng, despite limited resources, began his crusade against waste incineration primarily using radio broadcasts to raise awareness.

From these modest beginnings, TWI forged partnerships and lobbied tirelessly to reshape waste policies in Taiwan. Teaming up with the Worldwatch Institute in Washington D.C., TWI translated annual reports while advocating for a paradigm shift towards zero waste across sectors.

Today, TWI remains steadfast in its commitment to its founding ideals, employing translation, research, and policy advocacy to realize the vision of a waste-free world. We had the chance to talk with TWI’s Editor Yunchia Luo and Researcher Yichun Lin. They shared that despite TWI’s initial limitations, the organization has made significant strides by engaging with local community leaders, grassroots activists, and educators.

What are TWI’s top priorities?

Our top priority at TWI is achieving zero waste, as we believe it to be the foundation of all our endeavors. This commitment drives us to advocate for source reduction, waste separation, and composting initiatives. We’re particularly passionate about promoting volume-based waste fees to incentivize waste reduction, drawing inspiration from the success seen in cities where such policies are in place. 

Additionally, we’re dedicated to promoting clean production practices, especially in industries like petrochemicals and electronics. We constantly urge these industries to transition to eco-friendly methods and reduce the use of hazardous chemicals. It’s a challenge, as we often face resistance, but we continue to advocate for legislative reforms to support a circular economy. We consistently pressure the government to prioritize eco-friendly policies and reduce energy and water consumption in industries such as petrochemicals, steel, and electronics. However, we’re also aware of our limitations in influencing industry practices due to economic interests, but we remain steadfast in our pursuit of a waste-free future.

Group of people holding up signs.
Photo courtesy of Taiwan Watch Institute

What are the main ongoing campaigns of TWI?

For over two decades, TWI has led the anti-incineration movement in the country, persistently mobilizing communities by raising awareness about the harmful effects of incinerators despite government support for the practice. Moreover, TWI has played a key role in calling for legislation promoting sustainable resource management, emphasizing principles such as extended producer responsibility and at source reduction.

Lately, TWI has redirected its attention towards addressing PFAS, commonly referred to as “forever chemicals” which are associated with various illnesses, including cancer and thyroid disorders, as well as contamination in food packaging. The use of PFAS remains an overlooked global concern in Taiwan but we’re aiming to change that through testing and awareness initiatives, we seek to advocate for regulations governing PFAS substances, with the ultimate goal of eradicating their usage in food packaging.

Waste segregated into several bins and bags
Photo courtesy of Taiwan Watch Institute

What are your biggest accomplishments/achievements?

Our progress, though gradual, holds significant weight. Firstly, over decades, our efforts to educate citizens about the hazards of incineration policies have spurred a shift in waste management practices, favoring recycling systems over additional incinerators. Secondly, our initiatives in plastic education have heightened public awareness of plastic reduction and improved understanding of the plastic lifecycle. We’ve advocated for the government to phase out the use of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) in food packaging while promoting the development and adoption of alternative materials. Lastly, our community engagement efforts have encouraged citizens to participate in closely sorting waste for recycling, both in neighborhoods and schools. These achievements serve as catalysts for further sustainable development objectives.

What challenges are you facing? 

Our biggest challenge comes from society’s focus on economic growth over environmental protection. When an economy grows, environmental concerns often take a backseat. This shouldn’t be the case. We believe that the government could and should set limits on how resources are used and waste are generated, such as how much water and electricity a company can use and how they manage their waste. We’re teaming up with other environmental groups to push for laws that promote recycling and sustainability, but it’s an ongoing effort. Plus, we rely on donations from people like you to keep our work going.

What are the main environmental issues that your country/region is facing?

In Taiwan, our environmental challenges are deeply rooted in the relentless pursuit of economic growth. Our primary goal is to establish boundaries to address this core issue. We’ve made strides in waste management and in advocating for solutions. Our focus now is on refining legislation to strengthen the initiatives we introduced. Another concern is food safety, particularly regarding harmful chemicals in processed foods. We’re dedicated to raising awareness about these dangers and promoting safer consumption practices.  Finally, we’re championing a transition to cleaner energy sources and restoring ecosystems; environmental groups across the country share these key priorities.

Group of people holding up signs with Chinese text
Photo courtesy of Taiwan Watch Institute

How do you see your organization’s work evolving in the next few years?

Looking ahead, our organization is focused on several key initiatives to guide our future path. First, we will persist in translating international data, news, reports, and scientific findings to Mandarin to enrich our domestic knowledge base. This ensures that our efforts are well-informed and firmly grounded in robust evidence. Moreover, we are committed to cultivating stronger partnerships with international organizations and local NGOs, with a particular emphasis on addressing PFAS restrictions and promoting plastic reduction. Through close collaboration with like-minded entities, we can combine our expertise and resources to drive meaningful change on a global scale. Lastly, we maintain our dedication to collaborating closely with local schools and communities to implement environmental action projects, such as organizing closely-sorted collections for recycling. Through direct engagement with educational institutions and grassroots communities, we empower individuals to take proactive steps toward sustainability.

What are your thoughts on the waste crisis that many countries in your region (and in the world) are living in right now?

The waste crisis boils down to two main issues: the staggering amount of waste produced and then how we manage it. To tackle the first problem, we need to focus on source reduction, phase out the use of unnecessary, single-use products or packages with reusable or refillable ones, and to call on the government to set a cap on the amount of industrial waste generated.

In Taiwan, many people have benefited from efficient regular door-to-door waste collection services for years, leading people to overlook the severity of the waste crisis. However, relying heavily on incineration as a quick fix only masks the true harm of waste, hiding its toxicity in emissions and ash. This shortsighted approach fails to address the root cause of the issue.

Ultimately, the waste crisis is a symptom of the linear material economy, serving as a warning sign that we must address. While recycling plays a crucial role, source reduction remains the most effective solution, as outlined in the Waste Hierarchy.

Do you collaborate with partners in other regions? If so, how?

In our early years, our focus was primarily on translation work, with a particular emphasis on reports from the WorldWatch Institute. While the Institute may no longer be as active, we’ve maintained our commitment to translating important reports and studies, now sourcing them from organizations like GAIA or the International Pollutants Elimination Network (IPEN). We also assist in promoting webinars hosted by these organizations and occasionally participate as responders. Further, we collaborate on projects with GAIA and IPEN, helping to gather data from Taiwan, such as the recent PFAS in food packaging project. In the past, our partners from IPEN even visited Taiwan to collect samples from our incinerators’ bottom ash, while GAIA helped us track waste flow imported into Taiwan in 2015, leading to the exposure of illegal operations by recycling companies.

Adult and two kids segregating waste
Photo courtesy of Taiwan Watch Institute

How does your work on waste relate to social justice?

The injustice within our waste recycling system is glaring, particularly evident in how grassroots collectors and waste pickers struggle to carry out a living. In a recent incident in 2023, a small collection business was forced to shut down due to an anonymous report, highlighting the prevalent “not-in-my-backyard” (NIMBY) mentality. This business had been a lifeline for many informal waste pickers, offering a place for collecting and distributing recyclables. With its closure, the waste pickers, often elderly and frail, are now forced to trek long distances to alternative collection sites across the city, underscoring the discriminatory nature of our legal system.

The recycling market further perpetuates significant injustices against collectors. The government or processors (like paper mills), set baseline prices for recyclables that are underestimated which could not cover the cost of collection and separation, thereby squeezing the earnings of collectors. This system, informed by government funds and policy, favors centralized and automatized materials recovery facilities, marginalizes disadvantaged groups, and hinders social justice efforts.

To amplify the voices of waste collectors in our advocacy work, we collaborate with NGOs and groups dedicated to supporting informal waste workers. We, recognizing that existing regulations often work against them,  evaluate the cost of waste collection, separation, and storage, advocate for higher recycling fees to provide financial incentives for their crucial work, and call on the government to provide suitable spaces for the waste collectors in the cities, seeking to address the systemic barriers they face within the current legal framework. Despite their limited numbers, informal collectors play a vital role in waste management, and it’s high time that their contributions are acknowledged and valued by society.

Photo courtesy of Taiwan Watch Institute

Who do you admire most in environmental work?

Indigenous peoples are the backbone of environmental movements against harmful developments like incinerators and landfills. These brave individuals, deeply connected to their land, stand up against big corporations and authorities to protect their homeland. In one remarkable story from 2020, a group of villagers fought against a new landfill for nearly 20 years. Led by the village head and later his son, took extraordinary measures to stall the landfill company, including blocking the entrance with cement blocks and maintaining a 24/7 vigil for almost two years, despite most protesters being elderly. With support from NGOs like TWI and through public awareness, they successfully halted the landfill’s operation as the company’s permission expired. This stands as a monumental achievement in Taiwan’s environmental history.

Call for funding

Small regular donations are greatly appreciated to support the environmental advocacy efforts of the Taiwan Watch Institute. Donations of just NT$ 200.00 or 300.00 a month, equivalent to reducing the consumption of a cup of bubble tea per week or a bucket of fried chicken per month, can make a significant impact. If you’re interested in contributing and supporting their initiatives, visit Taiwan Watch Institute for more info.

a group of people holding a banner with the text that says, "Reject ADB's Dismantling of Safeguards".
CSOs unfurl banner during the session on safeguards (Photo courtesy of NGO Forum on ADB)

Tbilisi, Georgia – On Sunday (May 5), civil society groups from different regions collectively raised their objections over the Asian Development Bank’s (ADB) regressive safeguards policy which aims to avoid, protect, and mitigate environmental and social harms from its operations.  As soon as the banner was unfurled at the end of the Safeguards Session on May 5, other civil society groups and representatives of affected communities stood with their protest shirts stating  “Protect people and planet over profits”. 

The Bank prepared the draft Environmental and Social Framework with 10 standards for public consultation in light of the ongoing review and update of ADB’s 2009 Safeguard Policy Statement . GAIA has participated in the process of raising their recommendations and critical  analysis on the proposed safeguards policy. 

Since the beginning of the consultations last year, GAIA and other civil society movements have objected to the weakening of the safeguards by failing to recognize international environmental and social conventions and the minimum standards for protecting people and the environment. From the beginning of the review process, GAIA has raised that persistent organic pollutants known to be a byproduct of incinerators and hazardous waste are already being governed for bans and phaseouts but ADB has omitted these sparsely mentioned conventions from the 2009 Safeguards Policy in the draft. 

“The Basel, Rotterdam, Stockholm, and Minamata Conventions need to be in the draft policy to guide both the Bank and borrowers on how to ensure that no harm will be done from its project. ADB must show that it is a responsible international development actor upholding the highest standards of environmental and social protection and not an institution playing above international law”, Mayang Azurin, GAIA Asia Pacific Deputy Director said. 

Groups also dissented over the lack of guidance for meaningful consultations and guidance on addressing reprisals given that ADB’s high-risk projects are often invested in countries with limited safe spaces for civic participation. 

GAIA also objected to the use of pollution and carbon offsets in the draft as a license for polluters to continue with its harmful projects while on the other hand, has not given priority and the right of communities to say no to harmful projects. 

“A weakened safeguards mean more harm to the community and the environment. Local communities, indigenous peoples, and local civil society organizations have raised evidence of the harms of burn technologies on waste. ADB’s safeguards are unable to avoid these impacts because it has just been paperwork without truly consulting the grievances of impacted communities. The triple planetary crisis of biodiversity loss, pollution, and climate change must push the ADB to avoid delays in global commitments in addressing these issues.”, stated Abdul Ghofar, Pollution and Urban Justice Campaigner from WALHI Indonesia, during a session organized by the ADB’s Accountability Mechanism

Safeguards policy has been a critical tool for communities to hold the ADB accountable for its harmful projects. GAIA has monitored billions of dollars invested by the Bank through loans, technical assistance, and grants on waste-to-energy (WtE) incinerators, refuse-derived fuel (RDF), co-firing coal with wastes, carbon capture storage (CSC)  technologies, harmful and exclusionary waste management projects in the Philippines, Indonesia, Bangladesh, India, Thailand, Malaysia, Cambodia, Maldives, Vietnam, Myanmar, Uzbekistan, Marshall Islands, Mongolia, and China. The application and implementation of safeguards in these projects have been unsatisfactory. 

Azurin, who spoke in a panel on community voices on just energy transition, stressed that ADB proposals to use either biomass or plastic waste to co-fire with plants perpetuate the use of coal as fuel while creating new problems.  “These technologies create new problems and require government support and subsidies which are better spent for real renewable energy and zero waste solutions,” she said. 

We, the undersigned members of the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives – Asia Pacific and its allies, call on the ADB’s  Board of Directors to reject the diluted, regressive, and dangerous draft ADB Environmental and Social Framework (“draft ESF”), which is currently being presented without meaningful consultations with affected communities and civil society organizations.

What has been set in 2009 as a forward-looking safeguard policy for people and the planet is turning into an unbreakable shield of protection for industry polluters in a time of deep and intersecting crises of biodiversity, climate, pollution, and social inequalities.

While science, community experiences, and global policy agenda point to bans, phase-outs, and restrictions on the manufacturing, trade, transport, and use of globally known hazardous substances and materials such as persistent organic pollutants and mercury which are known to have adverse impacts on human health, ecosystem, or have potential for depletion of the ozone layer – ADB’s draft ESF has glaringly dropped key multilateral environmental agreements (MEA) governing these harmful and toxic substances and materials.  

Instead of keeping at pace with the recent amendments of these MEAs on the standards and targets to curb the most harmful pollutants to guide the Bank and its borrowers, the draft ESF has omitted previous references in the 2009 Safeguards Policy on the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants,  the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer and the Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Waste and their Disposal. Moreover, it also has ignored the Minamata Convention that governs mercury which is a known byproduct of waste-to-energy incinerators. 

In the heart of ignoring global consensus on the need for international standards, targets and cross-border cooperation on the management of hazardous wastes is ADB’s direction towards continued support for industries known to be using toxic wastes as inputs or producing hazardous emissions such as waste-to-energy incinerators, co-incineration of waste with coal and cement plants, refuse-derived fuel, fly ash “recycling”, among others. 

Not only does the draft ESF enable the Bank and its borrowers to circumvent obligations to these MEAs, but it also encourages the use of poor or non-existent national mechanisms to under-capacitated developing countries in governing hazardous wastes or rely on the World Bank’s equally inadequate environment and health standards (EHS) instead of supporting developing member-states in the region achieve the objectives of international law. 

The undermining of MEAs poses risks to significant long-term impacts on communities in developing countries that are already challenged with shrinking civic spaces, democratic backsliding, and being unjustly blamed for causing pollution and destroying ecosystems. 

Moreover, the draft ESF allows continued pollution through offsetting mechanisms that have been repeatedly offered as a default option in the draft ESF for borrowers should their projects create “unavoidable” pollution instead of avoiding damage in the first place. The truth is, that MEAs are telling us that hazardous waste must be restricted and ultimately eliminated in the immediate horizon. 

Real safeguarding of the Earth’s resources and preventing pollution starts with redesigning production systems and goods, reducing unwanted extraction, and developing safe and just reuse of waste materials. However, it is alarming that the draft ESF has not placed the proper safeguards to ensure that circular economy activities achieve a just and safe future for everyone, especially the most marginalized players in the conservation of material resources. 

Despite the critical roles of informal workers in material resource recovery, the draft ESF has not recognized and protected their rights as provided for by the International Labour Organisation (ILO) Recommendations 193, 204, and 205 which guide member-states on ensuring a just transition. 

If adopted, the current draft ESF risks reversing global efforts in addressing pollution and conserving material resources in a just and safe manner. 

We reject the draft ESF until the ADB moves toward upward harmonization with international consensus, including in emerging processes like the Global Plastics Treaty. 

We demand a progressive ESF policy with avoidance to harm and human rights at the center that empowers communities to say no to rights-violating, climate and debt-inducing projects, and toxic technologies that keep the region as markets for false solutions.

Read: Comments on the draft ADB Environmental and Social Framework

SIGN-ON FORM

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: APRIL 28, 2024

Ottawa, Canada– Global South leaders–including a Member State Delegate, frontline community leader, policy expert, and youth activist– will share their perspectives on the lastics treaty negotiations thus far. The stakes could not be higher–what happens in the rooms of the Shaw Center will have a direct and profound impact on our lives and the lives of our families and communities.

The imbalanced power dynamics between the Global North and Global South in the plastics treaty negotiations mirror the circumstances of the plastics crisis itself. The Global South has long been wrongfully accused as the source of plastic pollution, despite the fact that most plastic production and consumption is centered in the Global North. Furthermore, we have been the target of choice for illegal traffic and dumping of plastic waste, and are made to suffer its most severe impacts to our health, and natural environments. 

29 April, 1 PM Room 203, Shaw Centre
Ottawa, Canada 
Register for zoom livestream HERE.  

Panelists  

Santos Virgilio, Delegate of Member State Angola: Experience Negotiating for the Global South 

Ana Rocha, Global Plastics Policy Director, GAIA (Tanzania):  Policy Update on the Negotiations  and What it Means for the Global South

Dorothy Otieno, CEJAD, Kenya , GAIA Africa: Financial Mechanisms &  False Solutions

Alejandra Parra, GAIA Latin America and the Caribbean, RADA (Chile) 

Aeshnina Azzahra, River Warrior Indonesia, GAIA Asia Pacific: Waste Colonialism in the Global South

Press contacts:

GAIA Africa: Carissa Marnce, +27 76 934 6156,  carissa@no-burn.org

GAIA Asia Pacific: Sonia G. Astudillo, +63 9175969286, sonia@no-burn.org

GAIA América Latina: Camila Aguilera, +56 9 5 111 1599, camila@no-burn.org 

GAIA Global: Claire Arkin, +1 973 444 4869, claire@no-burn.org

For more information about GAIA’s treaty advocacy, please visit  no-burn.org/unea-plastics-treaty, follow us on X @gaianoburn, and read our Press kit.

###

GAIA is a worldwide alliance of more than 1,000 grassroots groups, non-governmental organizations, and individuals in over 90 countries. With our work we aim to catalyze a global shift towards environmental justice by strengthening grassroots social movements that advance solutions to waste and pollution. We envision a just, zero waste world built on respect for ecological limits and community rights, where people are free from the burden of toxic pollution, and resources are sustainably conserved, not burned or dumped. 

Ottawa, April 25, 2024 – Currently, countries around the world are gathering in Ottawa, Canada for the fourth Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee (INC) meeting to discuss the international agreement on plastics from April 23-29, 2024. In this session, AZWI highlights the presence of the plastic and chemical industries in the negotiation process as it poses a risk to achieving the objectives of the agreement, which is to regulate the entire life cycle of plastics to protect human health and the environment

On Tuesday, April 23, 2024, coinciding with the opening of INC-4, the INC Secretariat released a provisional list of conference participants distributed via email. According to this list, INC-4 is attended by about 4,000 people consisting of delegations from member states and observer participants from environmental organizations, scientists, to business entities such as petroleum, gas, petrochemical corporations, chemical industry associations, alternative plastic industries, and FMCGs (Fast Moving Consumer Goods).

From the provisional participant list released by the INC Secretariat, the 44 members of the Indonesian Delegation (DELRI) consist of representatives from the Coordinating Ministry for Maritime Affairs and Investment, the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Industry, the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries, the Ministry of National Development Planning, the Indonesian Embassy in Canada, and the National Coordination Team to Tackle Marine Debris.

Based on a quick analysis from Aliansi Zero Waste Indonesia (AZWI), at least four members of the Indonesian Delegation come from the plastic industry, such as Chandra Asri Petrochemical and bioplastic producer Greenhope. These plastic manufacturers’ representatives were registered as officials and experts from the Ministry of Industry to become official members of DELRI. The presence of these two plastic producers in the Indonesian Delegation could potentially weaken the Indonesian Government’s positions in negotiations regarding plastic production restrictions.

“The presence of plastic industry representatives in the negotiation room of the international plastic agreement, especially as part of a country’s delegation, clearly shows a conflict of interest in achieving a strong and binding agreement. Negotiators, including the Indonesian government, must learn from the WHO-supported UN Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (UNFCTC), which has successfully blocked commercial interests and tobacco industry involvement in the negotiation process,” said Abdul Ghofar, Urban Pollution and Campaign Manager at The Indonesian Forum for Environment (WALHI).

“The Involvement of industry in plastic negotiation meetings could weaken the negotiation position of Indonesia in making decisions related to the elimination of hazardous chemical additives in plastics that affect public health,” said Yuyun Ismawati, Senior Advisor at Nexus3. 

Instead of involving representatives from the plastic and chemical industries in the delegation, the Indonesian government should involve the Ministry of Health, Ministry of Labor, and scientific representatives who can provide substantive support in the process of negotiating the international agreement on plastics.

In response to the conflict of interests between the plastic and chemical industries and the Indonesian delegates, Aliansi Zero Waste Indonesia (AZWI), raised several points as follow:

  1. Condemn the Ministry of Industry of the Republic of Indonesia for incorporating representatives of the plastic and chemical industries into the Indonesia Delegation (DELRI) in the International Agreement on Plastics.
  2. Demand the Indonesian Government to remove industry representatives from the official Indonesian delegation in plastic treaty negotiation meetings.
  3. Demand the Indonesian Government to include representatives from the Ministry of Health, Ministry of Manpower, and scientists in the composition of DELRI.
  4. Ensure that the Indonesian Government’s position in the negotiation of the International Agreement on Plastics is not influenced by the interests of the plastic and chemical industries.
  5. Demand the Indonesian government not to accommodate representatives of the plastic and chemical industries in the DELRI membership during the negotiation of the International Agreement of Plastic, diplomatic conferences, and other formal meetings.
  6. Demand the Indonesian Government to give careful assessment to the economic, environmental, and public health cost caused by plastic pollution, and to consider regulatory changes that provide relief and subsidies to polluting industries.

— END –

Contact person:

Kia, Comms Officer AZWI | kia@aliansizerowaste.id | 0852 1580 9537 

Joel, Campaigner AZWI | joel@aliansizerowaste.id |  0878 8576 5536

Ahead of the ADB’s Annual Meeting next month, civil society groups are firmly calling on the Asian Development Bank (ADB) to go back to the drawing board and overhaul the draft Environmental and Social Framework (ESF) as written in its current form. To demonstrate their grave concerns that the policy provisions will undermine project-affected people and their allies abilities to hold ADB to account when social and environmental harms and damages occur, they intend to deliver a statement to the ADB Headquarters in Manila this morning.

The draft ESF, aimed at updating ADB’s safeguards policies, is being met with opposition from civil society groups due to a wide range of critical shortcomings, including:

  • Lack of Clear Lines of Accountability 
  • Lack of Clarity Related to the Stakeholder Engagement 
  • Lack of Human Rights Approach 
  • Weakened Environmental and Social Protections 
  • Gender Consideration Dilution 
  • Climate Change standards that fail to stand up to climate science 
  • Opaque Financial Intermediary Lending 

In light of these grave concerns, the NGO Forum on ADB and the Asian Peoples Movement on Debt and Development (APMDD) together with the Philippine Movement for Climate Justice (PMCJ), 350.org, Bukluran ng Manggagawang Pilipino (BMP), Freedom from Debt Coalition, Sanlakas, Oriang, K4K-QC, Zone One Tondo Organization (ZOTO), Center for Energy, Ecology and Development (CEED), Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (GAIA), Legal Rights and Natural Resources Center (LRC-KSK), EcoWaste Coalition, Coalition for Human Rights in Development (CHRD), Recourse and International Accountability Project (IAP)  urge the ADB to overhaul the draft ESF, revising the language to instead reflect a set of forward-looking safeguards applicable to its entire portfolio, grounded in international human rights and environmental standards.

Quotes from Civil Society Organizations (CSOs)

  1. ⁠”The ADB’s safeguards should be the backbone of the bank’s commitment to people and the ecosystem’s well-being. Prioritizing community consultation and consent in all energy projects is paramount, ensuring that local communities are empowered in decision-making, safeguarding their rights and livelihoods. For us, the well-being of people and planet are non-negotiable.” 

– Chuck Baclagon, Finance Campaigner 350.org Asia

  1. The ADB continues to subject people and planet to further harm. The latest draft of ADB’s Environmental and Social Framework (ESF) further dilutes already weak safeguards provisions for affected communities. Even worse, the Bank continues to  ignore opposition by communities and persists in pushing climate-exacerbating  programs and policies and debt-creating finance in many Asian countries.

The ADB should walk the talk of eradicating poverty. Heed peoples’ demand for debt cancellation, reparations for past and continuing harms, an end to financing of planet-warming fossil fuels, and a  rapid, equitable, and just energy transition.

  • Lidy Nacpil, Coordinator, Asian Peoples Movement on Debt and Development (APMDD) 
  1. As a bank with a legacy of dirty energy and harm, the least that ADB could do in the face of worsening climate crisis and environmental degradation is to produce and implement a most stringent ESF. Instead, the draft allows financing of projects whose risks are not yet fully assessed, problematically allows offsets, and neglects the need to fully stop new financing for coal or gas with no exceptions. Glaring loopholes essentially render the ESF useless in truly responding to climate and environmental imperatives. We are one in calling on ADB to thoroughly improve the ESF draft, and ensure that finance is instead channeled to genuine solutions such as distributed renewables.
  • Avril De Torres, Deputy Executive Director, Center for Energy, Ecology and Development (CEED)
  1. “The EcoWaste Coalition is troubled by the provision of the ESF that allows borrowers or clients to propose less stringent measures. This opens a door to potential abuses, where economic or political pressures could dilute the rigor of environmental and social protections.

If ADB is genuine in their stance to promote sustainable and responsible development, they should put stronger oversight, clearer criteria for exceptions, and more robust accountability in the ESF to uphold rigorous environmental and social standards.”

-Glory Rose Manatad, Legal and Policy Officer

Ecowaste Coalition

  1. ⁠“The failure of the ADB to accept any semblance of accountability for its past role in pushing policies that dismantled mechanisms and structures that protected people from corporate abuse or anti-people projects has again reared its ugly head. 

The weakening and dilution of existing safeguards is proof that ADB has not learned any lesson and remains more concerned with ensuring the profitability of the private sector rather than protecting the welfare of people or the future of the planet.”

-Rovik Obanil, Secretary General, Freedom from Debt Coalition (FDC)

  1. ADB has to recognize that we are already feeling the impacts of climate change, biodiversity loss and pollution. It has to stop giving corporations continued license to pollute and to burn our planet through hideous carbon and pollution offsets. The false solutions they promote trapping us into dirty debts and are severely impacting the environment and communities – most especially the poor and marginalized. It’s time for the Bank to wake up to the facts and finally align with international socio-environmental and human rights instruments!

-Brex Arevalo, GAIA AP Climate and Anti-Incineration Campaigner 

  1. “The ADB has an opportunity to ensure that governments uphold the right to self-determination of indigenous peoples. It should mandate the securing of the free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) of indigenous peoples within their ancestral domains. More importantly, the ADB must begin to subscribe to the framework of the “Right to Say No” of indigenous peoples and move beyond “meaningful consultation,” which the FPIC process has sadly become. The reverse of the Right to Say No is the community’s Right to Say Yes to their own model of development.” 

-Maya Quirino, Advocacy Coordinator, Legal Rights and Natural Resources Center-Kasama sa Kalikasan/Friends of the Earth Philippines (LRC-KsK/FoE Phils.)

  1. The ESF W Paper, after two years of consultations, regrettably fails to integrate any of the comments provided by civil society, which have consistently demanded stringent requirements for ADB borrowers to adhere to environmental and social compliance principles, committed to “Do No Harm.” The mitigating hierarchy approach promoted by the ADB in this draft ESF poses a direct threat to communities and the environment globally. It undermines all prerequisites for environmental and social risk assessment and compliance prior to loan approval, granting borrowers absolute freedom to disregard environmental and social risks. This constitutes a dismantling of the fundamental notion of safeguards.

We strongly condemn the ADB’s current ESF draft at its 57th annual meeting and demand a complete overhaul to ensure mandatory risk assessment requirements before loan approval, with language compliant with independent investigations for all ADB borrowers. Anything less than this poses a direct threat to communities and the environment.

-Rayyan Hassan, Executive Director, NGO Forum on ADB

  1. “As it stands, the ESF allows for the continuation of projects that worsen climate change. Fossil fuel use should have stopped by 2025. This should be reflected by the ESF, with stringent policies barring the financing of any more fossil fuel projects. If not, it fails to safeguard the environment or any community.”

-Ian Rivera, National Coordinator of the Philippine Movement for Climate Justice

  1. “This draft safeguards policy does little to rectify the black hole that is ADB’s financial intermediary lending. Communities harmed by ADB investments have a right to seek remedy, but there can be no accountability if we can’t see where the money is really coming from. The Bank’s safeguards for intermediary lending need drastic improvement, to ensure full transparency about its involvement in all projects it funds – including clear disclosure of ADB financing at project sites and in community consultations.”

-Kate Geary, Co-Director, Recourse

PHILIPPINES, Quezon City, 21 March 2024 – In a significant move for labor rights and environmental justice, waste workers and waste pickers from diverse regions across the Philippines gathered for a national consultation, forming a national alliance and demanding a Magna Carta for Waste Workers — marking a historic and unified call for the recognition of their rights.

From Manila to Siquijor, representatives of various waste picker and waste worker groups voiced concerns regarding their social conditions, ranging from job insecurity to exposure to health hazards to the imperative need for humane working conditions, better pay, health benefits, and protection against discrimination. The delegates, representing over 1,000 waste workers and waste pickers from across the country, determined that despite their diversity, they have similar and resounding aspirations, all of them having faced a form of marginalization and discrimination in their line of work.

Following their emotional sharing of experiences and visions, Marina Cuyugan, Treasurer of Women Waste Warrior (Manila), persuaded her colleagues to form a national alliance. “Everything we discussed today will not become a reality if we don’t organize ourselves. We need to form a national organization. If we don’t, who will listen to us?” she told her fellow participants.

Thus, the establishment of the Philippine National Waste Workers Alliance (PNWWA) — the first-ever national alliance of such kind in the country — as a unified front to advocate for their demands and their rights.
Aloja Santos, president of Dumaguete Women Waste Workers Association and founding president of the newly-formed alliance, vowed to lobby for the adoption of a magna carta for waste workers embodying their demands and aspirations. “If there is one thing we must accomplish, it is having a law that is grounded on our realities and responsive to our needs,” she said.

“We must be given social benefits and protection because we provide essential services to society. We are as deserving of such benefits and protection as any other worker. Perhaps even more so. Without us, society will not function efficiently. People just need to recognize our contributions to see that,” she added.
For Wilhelmina Magdaluyo, President of the Malabon-Navotas Waste Workers Association (MaNaWWA), benefits due to waste workers should not be subject to the whims of local politicians. “Many of our peers have been removed from work when there is a change of leadership after an election, despite doing hard work for more than 10 or 20 years. We need to ensure that every waste worker in the country gets the same protection,” she said. As a first step, the delegates formulated 10 demands which will be embodied in a draft magna carta that they plan to submit to the senate.

  1. Enforcement of Labor Standards (Pagpapatupad ng mga Pamantayan ng Trabaho)
    Enforcement of labor standards protects waste workers from being exploited, ensuring proper compensation and protection of rights.
  2. Hazard Pay (Bayad sa Panganib)
    Given the waste workers’ unsafe working conditions and exposure to health risks such as hazardous materials, the provision of hazard pay is a concrete demonstration of the recognition of waste workers’ rights.
  3. Health Insurance and Services (Seguro at Serbisyong Pangkalusugan)
    Access to health benefits and provision of essential medical care and support ensures waste workers’ safety and security.
  4. Humane and Safe Working Conditions (Makatao at Ligtas na Kalagayan sa Pagtatrabaho)
    The health and safety risks that waste workers face should be a thing of the past. It is imperative upon the government to ensure safe working conditions for all workers, especially those managing waste. Provision of personal protective equipment (PPE) is just one of the basic actions that must be carried out to ensure waste workers’ safety.
  5. Job Security (Seguridad sa Trabaho)
    Waste workers lack job security. Many face the risk of layoffs or contract terminations, resulting in financial instability and economic vulnerability. Providing job security not only allows for financial stability and security but also promotes commitment and reliability in the long term.
  6. Just Compensation (Tamang Pasahod)
    Fair wages for waste workers not only ensure economic security, it also recognizes the essential role of waste workers in communities as frontliners.
  7. Meaningful participation in policy spaces (Makabuluhang Pakikilahok sa mga Espasyo ng Patakaran)
    Waste workers have the experience and expertise that can meaningfully contribute to our communities’ waste management policies. Waste workers’ voices should be at the front and center of policy discussions for just, informed, and effective policies.
  8. Right to Organize (Karapatang Mag-organisa)
    The formation of the Philippine National Waste Workers Association (PNWWA) allows waste workers to have proper representation in policy spaces. An organized group is better equipped at advocating for basic rights and better working conditions. This also grants an opportunity for collective action and empowerment of waste workers in the Philippines.
  9. Social Benefits and Protection (Kapakinabangan at Proteksyong Panlipunan)
    Waste workers are among the most vulnerable sectors in society, facing security and health risks, economic instability, and even social discrimination. Access to social benefits and protection is critical in addressing these issues, allowing for dignified labor and more humane living conditions.
  10. Training (Pagsasanay)
    Since waste pickers and waste workers deal with hazardous materials, training for safe-handling is essential to ensure safe working conditions. Skills training will also be useful for work outside the waste sector.

Mother Earth Foundation (MEF) Chairman Sonia Mendoza lauded the waste workers for organizing themselves. “Despite being praised as environmental heroes for their contributions to society, waste workers face numerous challenges. Being an organized group provides them advantages such as collective bargaining power, better sectoral representation and recognition, and access to capacity training,” she said.


She added, “MEF’s Zero Waste City models would not be successful without the hard work, commitment, and dedication of waste workers. Yet the invaluable help of these unsung heroes in our Zero Waste work is often ignored and not given importance, especially by the government. The significant strides that the Zero Waste movement has achieved would not have been possible in the Philippines and around the world without waste workers.”


Various estimates place the number of waste workers and waste pickers in the Philippines at over 100,000 under the informal waste sector, but waste worker groups and their partner NGOs believe this is a gross underestimation. Waste workers and waste pickers often work in open dumpsites and wander around cities collecting trash on-foot or with carts, thus their numbers are mostly unrecorded. And while considered essential workers, waste workers are underpaid and overworked, with only 4,000 (.04%) waste workers nationwide reported to receive annual wages at around P250,000 in materials recovery, waste collection, and waste treatment and disposal.


“We call on the government to ensure a just transition for informal workers in the waste sector by once and for all listening to their voices and immediately acting on improving their working and living conditions. The waste workers and waste pickers are not asking for far too much. All they are demanding is that they be accorded their fundamental rights as Filipinos, and as workers whose contributions greatly benefit society,” said Sherma Benosa, lead of the Just Transition work of GAIA Asia Pacific.

“They are not only the backbone of efficient resource and waste management, they also play a central role in climate change mitigation. If we are to succeed in our fight against plastic pollution and climate change, we need to support our frontliners — the waste workers and waste pickers,” she added.

a group pf people standing in front of a waste management facility.
Waste pickers and waste workers pose with hospital administrators, and HECAF 360, GAIA, and WALHI staff in front of the waste management facility.

On March 3, waste workers and waste pickers from Indonesia and the Philippines visited a Zero Waste hospital in Kathmandu, Nepal, days after they staged a march together with other representatives from various countries in the Asia Pacific region to celebrate International Waste Pickers Day on March 1. 

The  Armed Police Force Hospital is one of the 22 Zero Waste hospitals in Nepal that proudly implement waste management and recovery programs through the assistance of GAIA member, HECAF360.

A person holding a piece of paper
Prerana Dangol, Senior Program Officer at HECAF 360, explains the stringent treatment and testing process of infectious waste

During the visit, HECAF360’s Executive Director Mahesh Nakarmi and Senior Program Officer, Prerana Dangol, showed the visitors their comprehensive waste management process, from the consistent use of color-coded bins to at-source waste segregation to the treatment of infectious waste to the recovery of recyclables, all the while emphasizing the importance of good governance in the success of the program.

“Not many people understand the link between hospitals and waste pickers, but the reason we’re working on hospital waste management is to ensure the safety of waste pickers. A huge percentage of hospital waste is infectious. Anything that has had contact with body fluids – syringes, blood bags, ampules – is infectious. This type of waste must be treated before they are discarded or recovered,” Nakarmi told the visitors.

a person pointing at a poster
Mahesh Nakarmi, Executive Director, HECAF 360

“Without proper hospital waste management, the infectious waste may end up in landfills untreated, causing harm to waste pickers who recover these resources. I tell the doctors: ‘We say, do no harm, but if you do not have good waste management in your hospitals, you may be saving your patients’ lives, but you might be [unwittingly] harming the life of others — the people who are forced to manage improperly disposed of hospital waste,” he added.

Accompanied by GAIA and Wahana Lingkungan Hidup Indonesia (WALHI) staff, the Filipino and Indonesian contingents were in the Nepali capital to attend the first regional congress of the International Alliance of Waste Pickers-Asia Pacific, of which many of them are members.